Terri asks a great question after the last blog entry, with the 417 Rules of Awesomely Bold Leadership:
Maybe I am a moron, but I do not get what is being satirized in this post. Usually I get you and love this blog. I feel left out since I don't get it. Can someone explain?
Terri, here's a long answer: I just read a "leadership" book a friend gave me. He was laughing when he handed it to me, last week, because he knew I would get a kick out of it.
It starts with a great story, typical of the genre: Essentially, "So there I was, on the football field, and I just got my arm broken after I smashed the running back. My coach said, "You get back in there," so I did. I finished that game with a broken arm and 16 tackles. It was right then and there when I learned you have to be tough to be a leader..."
The rest of the book is loaded with anecdotes about how awesome the author was and remains and forever will be, amen.
And in the forward, essentially this, about the author: "This man has won in high school football, won in college, won as a coach, and he wins at church, so you should be thankful he's taken the time to share his winning ways with you..." etc.
These books are largely self-congratulatory, and will make you come away saying, "Wow, that guy's quite the man!" And -- far worse -- given their understandings of leadership, Jesus Himself would need to read them, because He clearly didn't succeed. He was homeless, had only a small band of followers (who deserted him) and wound up lonely and then killed by the authorities.
Ah, success!
Few are the "leadership" books and seminars that would reinterpret leadership in light of Jesus. (Though, I'm sure there are, out there, some redeeming ones.) Instead, they tend to celebrate an American corporate idea of what a real man should be. Of course, I loves me some America, and obviously, I'm a real man (hello, I play accordion) but flexing one's "success" muscles in front of a paying public? Let's call it for what it is. It's isn't leadership. It's an ego trip.
You can read the series (click here) -- but I can tell you, there's not one thing I've satirized that isn't echoed in the leadership materials out there. They do it with a straight face, which is why people who've read these books can read my satire with a glint of pained recognition.
I once read an audacious book that tried to synthesize Jesus' leadership example with the typical Alpha-Guy American one. (Hey, at least the author tried.) One "rule" was, "Make time for everyone. Jesus always did, etc." and another "rule" was, essentially, "Don't waste time with nobodies, you have to prioritize who's important," etc. Okay.
It's my belief that Jesus is the Greatest Leader Ever. But he was, by any reasonable American standard, one real big failure as CEO.
But, overall, the books really don't tend to deal much with Jesus. We're supposed to just presume that being an Awesomely Awesome Leader is what Jesus wants, because Jesus loves big successes in the church world, and why wouldn't He? Right?
And if you aren't succeeding, Pastor Man? Well, you haven't applied all the rules. Or haven't read them all. Or didn't subscribe to the series on CD. Or, if you have done those things? Well, let's face it: You're not the man the Leader of Leaders is. On Saturdays, while you're trying to fix your minivan? He's golfing with Big Christian Athletes. You're not him. You're little you.
I say if that's "success", here's to the faithful failures; people with true pastoral hearts, serving people God has brought across their paths, never getting book deals, never selling motivational CDs, and always aware that God humbles the proud, and exalts the humble.
Recent Comments